Skip to main content
A1 A1
top story
Victims of Sparta earthquake still rebuilding two months after quake rocked mountain counties

SPARTA — The cell phone sitting on Daniel Roten’s desk Thursday morning buzzed every few minutes.

That’s not at all unusual. Roten serves as the emergency management coordinator in Alleghany County, and so his phone has been ringing nearly nonstop since an earthquake the morning of Aug. 9 shook locals to their core and caused millions in damages.

“That’s the state,” he said after looking at the number. “I’ll call them back.”

Roten decided to let the call roll to voicemail because the task at hand seemed a little more urgent.

He had a chance to update North Carolinians beyond the 11,000 souls in his county about what had been lost, how much work remains and urge continued patience with a rebuilding process that’s taking longer than many might like.

“We’re getting there,” he said. “It’s a slow process. We’re trying to make sure we do it correctly. I try to tell people that the bigger the government wheel is, the slower it turns.

“This is a huge undertaking.”

Signs of lasting damage

The scars left behind by an earthquake, which measured an eye-opening 5.1 magnitude, are everywhere. But you have to look for them.

“It wasn’t like a hurricane or a tornado where you can just drive down the street and see that everything is flattened,” Roten said.

Nor did the quake resemble anything like the 6.9 magnitude monster in 1989 near San Francisco that killed 63, caused $6 billion in damage and halted a World Series.

The damage left in Alleghany County is more insidious, and in many ways, more difficult to fix. Worse still, next to no one carried an earthquake rider on their insurance. "I can count the number on one hand," Roten said.

Homes along a high ridge off U.S. 21 show cracks in brick walls and cinder-block foundations. Parking lots and pavement next to small businesses buckled, allowing stormwater runoff inside walls and ceilings. Roofs, doors and window frames shifted.

Some 500 buildings were damaged; 60 suffered “major” damage, a term used by government agencies that means it equals 40 percent of a structure’s value.

The estimated total so far: $15 million and counting.

“That may not sound like a lot, but it’s very impactful here,” Roten said. “If this happened in the Triangle or Winston-Salem, (damage) would have been astronomical.”

On a micro-level, in the eyes and wallets of small business and individual homeowners, the August earthquake was catastrophic.

“We’re just trying to keep the water out,” said Juan Carlos Nordelo, the owner of the Tex Mex Riverside Restaurant. “See? Here and here.”

Nordelo was pointing to cracks to a slab of sidewalk that runs the length of his building, which sits just above the Little River. His roof was bowed, too, in a wavy pattern caused by a tremor that lasted mere seconds.

Cracks resembling stairsteps appeared in the walls of his basement storage area and water pipes burst, forcing him to close for two days. He’s done a lot of the repair work with his own hands, including caulking and attempting to seal the sidewalk breaks with concrete he mixed himself.

Two days after the quake, Gov. Roy Cooper, a coterie of aides, state troopers and an attendant media horde from as far away as Charlotte toured the town and surveyed the damage.

Cooper stood in Nordelo’s restaurant, asking smart questions and talking up disaster aid that would surely flow to the county and surrounding areas. “He promised us,” Nordeo said.

That assistance, though, has been hard to come by for an immigrant living the American dream. A letter denying his application for a low-interest loan administered by the U.S. Small Business Administration arrived Wednesday. “They said we didn’t have enough (income),” Nordelo said.

Still, he’s persevering, planning and counting his blessings. His daughter is an honors student at Appalachian State University, and his family is strong-willed enough to repair what they can when they can.

“I’ll fix it little by little,” he said. “This is home. We’re working. Not a lot of money (coming in) but we made a life here.”

'People were on edge anyway'

Over in the emergency services office in the county building, Roten knows what Nordelo is experiencing. He’s heard similar stories from other small business owners along with nearly opposite accounts from homeowners who’ve had good experiences in applying for aid.

The issue here is that the earthquake, while locally devastating, didn’t rise to the level of a federal disaster. “It wasn’t big enough for FEMA” is the way Roten explains it.

So in this case, Cooper declared a state-level disaster, which set in motion freeing up already budgeted state emergency aid and activating the federal Small Business Administration to oversee the loan process for businesses and homeowners.

As of Thursday, the SBA had received 69 loan applications and approved 28 for $734,100 for businesses and residents in Alleghany and nearby counties, wrote Janel Finley, an SBA public-affairs specialist in an e-mail. The deadline for loan applications is Oct. 26.

Additionally, the N.C. General Assembly approved in September another $24 million in relief. “We didn’t expect that and we had to quickly design a program to get that out through the state budget and management office,” said Keith Acree, a spokesman for the state emergency management division.

On a practical level, that means disaster-relief grants of up to $68,000 will be available to qualified applicants.

That’s helpful. So, too, is a decision from Raleigh to hire two workers — including a general contractor to speed damage assessments — to be based in Sparta to handle applications.

“It’s possible people will be able to get those grants and use them to repay SBA loans,” Acree said.

Still, hearing from locals frustrated by the difficulties faced by some small business owners is hard since many of them are friends and neighbors.

“I don’t want to bite the hand that’s helping us and I get that (government) can’t be deciding who wins and who loses in private business,” Roten said. “I can tell homeowners to be patient, that help is on the way. But small business owners, I can’t say ‘Help might be on the way. But we just don’t know.’ You can’t tell people that.

“It has been slow, but the state has been really good overall and very helpful.”

Some locals are reacting with a stereotypical sense of mountain independence and not counting on outside help.

As soon as Adam Woodel realized the extent of the damage to his business — geologists told him City Limit Tire sits atop the fault line — he got busy.

“I was told that it’d cost $150,000 to $200,000 to take everything down and rebuild,” he said.

But that’s not an option for a business with four employees that sells tires online and ships directly to customers.

Instead, Woodel hired a contractor to repair the drop ceiling in the business office, another to rehang bay doors that were damaged, a plumber to install new toilets and check water lines and found a fourth to seal cracks in the concrete slab floor of his huge metal pre-fab warehouse.

He’s out a few thousand bucks and expects the final tally to run past $10,000 for piecemeal repairs. “Other people got it worse,” he said.

Another worry was a series of seven small quakes throughout the day Tuesday that roiled the area.

“Tiny” sneered online smart-alecks who didn’t face losing a life’s work. “Didn’t feel so small here,” Roten said. “2.4 is enough to get your attention.”

Locals immediately recalled “pre-shocks” from a similarly sized tremor the day before the bigger one. “People were on edge anyway,” Roten said.

Woodel was one of those. Until he recalled a casual conversation he’d had with a scientist digging a hole behind his warehouse to study the earthquake.

“I was worried that it could happen again,” he said. “But the geologist said the pressure (underground) has been relieved so it’s very unlikely to happen again in my lifetime.”

Residents of a small county resting uneasily along fault lines in the Blue Ridge Mountains certainly hope so.

Photos: Two Months After Sparta's Magnitude 5.1 Earthquake

Danby House, site of alleged fight between residents that was encouraged by employees, sued by one of the residents

Danby House — the assisted-living facility where three employees were accused of inciting two female residents to fight each other last year — is facing a lawsuit filed by one of those residents. 

Attorneys for Betty Elaine Moore, a 75-year-old resident at Danby House, filed the lawsuit Wednesday in Forsyth Superior Court against Danby House LLC; ALG Senior LLC, which operates Danby House; and the three women who face charges in the incident that occurred on June 19, 2019. On Monday, Oct. 12, the women — Marilyn Latish McKey, 33; Tonacia Yvonne Tyson, 21; and Tanesha Deshawn Jordan, 27 — were all indicted on misdemeanor charges of assaulting an individual with a disability. ALG Senior LLC was formerly Affinity Living Group LLC. The company changed its name in June.

According to court documents, Forsyth County prosecutors allege that the three women encouraged Moore and a 71-year-old resident to fight each other. The lawsuit alleges that the three women shared the videos with other people, some of whom posted one of the videos to YouTube. According to a search warrant, Jordan recorded the fight and shared it with others. Tyson recorded a second incident in which McKey is alleged to have pushed Moore into her room. That video was also shared, the search warrant said.

Documents from the N.C. Department of Health and Human Services and the lawsuit allege that the 71-year-old resident hit Moore repeatedly and choked her. The lawsuit alleges that the three workers did not intervene in the fight and failed to notify supervisors. The lawsuit also alleges that officials at Danby House, when told of the incident, did not contact Winston-Salem police. According to a search warrant, Alexandria Johnson, an employee, contacted police on June 21, 2019, the same day that a staff meeting was held during which Brooke Wood, regional vice president of operations for what was then known as Affinity Living Group LLC, talked about the incident. 

The lawsuit makes several claims, including negligent hiring, supervision and retention and medical negligence. 

In a news release, Daniel Donovan, one of the attorneys for the woman, said the company should be held accountable.

"The actions of Ms. McKey, Ms. Tyson, and Ms. Jordan are indefensible," he said. "However, it is the corporation and the corporate decision-makers that are truly to blame for their policies of hiring unqualified staff, failing to properly train them, then leaving them unsupervised with the most vulnerable patients." 

In a statement Friday, Danby House said, "While we traditionally do not comment on pending litigation, and have not been served with a copy of the complaint, this was an isolated incident of criminal misconduct by three former Danby House employees. Danby House does not, and has never, condoned such egregious misconduct, which is contrary to the training, policies and values of this community. At all times, Danby House has fully cooperated with law enforcement and will continue to do so."

According to the lawsuit, Moore was in the Special Care Unit, which is reserved for residents suffering from dementia and Alzheimer's. On June 19, 2019, she was in her room when the other woman came into her room. The lawsuit said the 71-year-old resident had a history of coming into other resident's rooms and agitating them. She had come into Moore's room before, causing conflict, the lawsuit said.

McKey, Jordan and Tyson, all personal care aides, had come into Moore's room to check on her roommate, who had fallen. The 71-year-old resident began hitting Moore, knocking her back onto her bed, and then started choking her until "she was close to losing consciousness." 

The lawsuit said McKey, Jordan and Tyson did not do anything and in fact, encouraged the two female residents to fight each other. Another employee, a medication aide, also witnessed the attack but did not alert supervisors, the lawsuit said. 

On June 20, 2019, the regional vice president for Danby found out about the incident through text messages and asked about the incident at a staff meeting the next day, the lawsuit said. According to the lawsuit, the regional vice president failed to contact authorities or Moore's family. A search warrant identifies the regional vice president as Brooke Wood.

After the incident, the N.C. Department of Health and Human Services barred Danby House from admitting new residents because of numerous patient-care deficiencies. The deficiencies, laid out in documents filed last year, said that employees were not properly trained and that they failed to administer medications to residents as prescribed by a doctor. NCDHHS also found evidence that employees allowed, and in some cases encouraged, the residents to fight. The employees videotaped some of the fights because they didn't like one of the residents involved.

Danby House has had a history of having deficiencies, according to records with the N.C. Department of Health and Human Services. As of Sept. 29, Danby House did not have any deficiencies. 

The lawsuit is seeking at least $25,000 in compensatory damages and an unknown amount of punitive damages.