Skip to main content
You are the owner of this article.
You have permission to edit this article.
Mount Airy man sentenced to more than 20 years in fatal Winston-Salem shooting.

Mount Airy man sentenced to more than 20 years in fatal Winston-Salem shooting.

  • 0

A Forsyth County judge kept wondering how Charlie Andrew Goldsmith ended up standing before him Monday afternoon.

“It’s hard to see how we got here,” Judge Allen Baddour of Forsyth Superior Court told Goldsmith.

Minutes before, Goldsmith, 23, of Red Barn Lane in Mount Airy, had pleaded guilty to second-degree murder in the 2018 death of Jordan Anthony Gabriel, who was 21. A Forsyth County prosecutor alleged Goldsmith shot Gabriel in the parking lot outside a Food Lion off Stratford Road after the two men had an argument over a drug deal.

“No amount of marijuana is worth a life,” Baddour said.

Goldsmith had been facing a first-degree murder charge, but as part of a plea arrangement, he was allowed to enter a guilty plea to second-degree murder. Assistant District Attorney Penn Broyhill and Goldsmith’s attorney, Paul James, reached an agreement on the sentence.

Baddour sentenced Goldsmith to a minimum of 18 years and a maximum of 22 years, 8 months, in prison.

Broyhill said that the shooting happened on July 27, 2018. Winston-Salem police officers responded to the parking lot at 8:30 p.m. that day.

Goldsmith and Gabriel had communicated earlier that day and had arranged to meet in the Food Lion parking lot at 2530 Somerset Center Drive. Gabriel drove his Honda Accord, and Goldsmith arrived in a separate car driven by someone else.

Broyhill said Goldsmith and another man, Keelan Goodwin, got into Gabriel’s car. Gabriel indicated that he did not have the marijuana, and Goldsmith said he wouldn’t pay until he saw the drugs. The two men started arguing.

Broyhill said Goldsmith is shown on surveillance camera footage getting out of Gabriel’s car and going to the car he arrived in. It’s not clear whether he already had a firearm or went to the car to get one.

Either way, Goldsmith went to the front passenger side of Gabriel’s car. Goodwin, who was in the back seat, later told police that he saw Gabriel lean back and put his hands up. Gabriel also appeared to be trying to drive away.

James said Goldsmith told police that he was standing by Gabriel’s passenger side door, which was open. When Gabriel accelerated, the car door closed on his hand, which held the gun. The gun then accidentally went off.

Gabriel was shot in the chest but was able to drive to the Sheetz gas station in the parking lot. People at the gas station were able to flag down a police officer. That officer and another officer tried to save Gabriel’s life. Gabriel was taken to a local hospital, where he died.

Goldsmith left the scene but was arrested on July 31, 2018, at a motel in Stokes County, Broyhill said. The gun that killed Gabriel was found in the motel and Goldsmith gave a full statement to police admitting his role in the shooting, Broyhill said.

Marcus Anthony Gabriel, Jordan Gabriel’s father, read a statement to the court. He wore a black shirt emblazoned with his son’s image on the front. On the back were these words: “Your wings were ready but my heart was not.”

Marcus Gabriel described his son as an “all-around good man” who loved his family, particularly his brother and two sisters. One of the last things his son told him before his death was for Marcus Gabriel to take care of his siblings.

He said Goldsmith didn’t just take his son’s life.

“You took part of my soul. I have to live with this the rest of my life until I see him again (in heaven),” he said.




Sign up for our Crime & Courts newsletter

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

Forsyth County District Attorney Jim O'Neill announced that 30,000 people will have their criminal records expunged. The people were convicted at a time when state law treated anyone 16 and 17 as adults. Because of that, their convictions were public record. Juvenile records are sealed. O'Neill said he wanted to even the playing field so that people convicted before the law changed would have the same benefit as 16 and 17-year-olds convicted now. 

Former Forsyth County GOP chair Nathan Tabor is facing new charges. This time, he is accused of conspiring with another man to steal and then sell a $6,000 golf cart. Over the past few months, Tabor, who chaired the Forsyth County Republican Party from 2009 to 2012 and has run for political office, has been charged with criminal offenses in three different counties, including Forsyth. He is accused of stealing items, such as catalytic converters in Brunswick County and cyberstalking family members in Catawba County, for which he was acquitted, and cyberstalking his former pastor. 

A Winston-Salem man has been indicted for second-degree murder in the death of his younger brother. Search warrants said home surveillance video showed the man carrying a sword up the stairs and later leaving the house with an assault rifle. The man told police that the rifle accidentally discharged during a fight with his brother, who he said was on Xanax. But police said in search warrants that the man's statements contradicted the physical evidence. 

Kalvin Michael Smith has filed a new appeal, seeking to overturn his conviction in the 1995 assault of Jill Marker, an assistant manager at the now-closed Silk Plant Forest store. His motion, filed Tuesday, cites newly-discovered evidence that his attorneys say prove his innocence, including a new witness who told police he saw a white man matching the description of the late Kenneth Lamoureux, enter the store just after 8:30 p.m. Dec. 9, 1995, with a Maglite flashlight. Smith's attorneys say police detectives ignored this and withheld other potentially favorable evidence to ensure Smith's conviction. 

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


Breaking News

News Alert