Skip to main contentSkip to main content
You have permission to edit this article.
top story
Our view

Our view: Depravity brought to life

  • 0

The discovery that a 9-year-old boy was allegedly forced to live outdoors inside a dog kennel, as the Journal’s John Hinton reported last week, is shocking. It’s so difficult to believe it could have happened — that any adult, let alone the child’s guardians, would have treated him this way.

It’s difficult to believe that this has been the situation since April, as the boy told an investigator.

But it’s a sign, perhaps, that for all of our technological and social advances, some serious degree of ignorance, depravity or evil still exists in our very state. It’s a warning for the rest of us that similar situations may exist within our scope of vision and influence.

The boy was rescued last Wednesday from outside a 1,400 square-foot Davidson County house — one in which three adults and four other children lived — following an anonymous call to the sheriff’s office. The boy apparently had been told that there wasn’t enough room inside for him.

He was found wearing a T-shirt, jeans and no shoes, despite the 28-degree temperature the night before he was rescued and frost on the ground that morning.

He was treated at Brenner Children’s Hospital. A warrant said he suffered a serious mental or emotional injury. That’s no surprise.

His father and step-mother, Jonathan Scott Starr and Sarah Lynette Starr, were arrested and are being charged with felony child abuse, misdemeanor child abuse and false imprisonment. Sarah Starr’s aunt, Shelly Lucille Barnes, who owns the house, was arrested and is being charged with felony child abuse, misdemeanor child abuse and false imprisonment, as well as possession of a firearm by a felon and maintaining a dwelling place for controlled substances, the sheriff’s office told the Journal.

Some of the details are still a little sketchy. Somehow, in the midst of this, Sarah Starr expressed that she and her husband were upset about the boy being held in the dog cage, the warrant said.

Were they helpless? What kind of pathology is at work here?

It sounds like some sick horror movie. But it’s all too real.

We’re eager to learn that the parties responsible for this torture will be properly punished. Severely punished. They’re scheduled to appear in court on Nov. 10.

In the meantime, every resource available should be provided to make sure the boy recovers from his ordeal — and that it’s not repeated.

As severe as this incident is, it’s not, unfortunately, the only example of child abuse in our state. More than 3,000 children in Forsyth County were assessed for abuse or neglect in 2020, according to NC Child — 38.9 out of every 1,000 — and those are only the ones who were reported. In Davidson County, more than 2,000 children were assessed in 2020 — 61.7 out of every 1,000. Statewide, more than 110,000 cases of child abuse were investigated in 2019.

Abuse doesn’t have to be physical; it can also be mental or emotional, with consequences just as serious and, in some cases, deadly. Bullying — in person and practiced on social media — has led some vulnerable children to hurt themselves — there were 2,971 emergency room visits for self-harm in kids between the ages of 10 and 18 in North Carolina in 2020, according to NC Health News — or even to commit suicide. Societal expectations sometimes put them at risk.

LGBTQ kids are at even greater levels of risk from bullying and abuse.

A lack of access to proper food and medical care also puts children at risk — one more reason General Assembly leaders should get off their butts today and pass Medicaid expansion.

It should go without saying that all forms of bullying should be prohibited in our schools.

And then there are the guns. As we write, we’re learning of another school shooting at a St. Louis high school in which several students were injured.

And some parents lost their minds over masks.

This is untenable. It’s unconscionable.

We like to think that childhood is a time of innocence, a time in which young people are allowed to make friends, follow their curiosity and young passions, learn how to be independent — while being protected from harm by their parents and guardians. They need nutrition and support — both physical and emotional.

Too many have failed them. It’s past time to stop gate-keeping their access to resources like food and counseling. Fully fund schools, fully fund human and health services and vote for candidates who will treat children like they matter.

And when you see a child possibly being abused — report it, for God’s sake.

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

When we think about the changes coming soon to the streets of Winston-Salem, we can’t help but remember William F. Buckley Jr.’s description o…

As Lee Newspapers’ Public Service Journalism team reported on Sunday, one in five North Carolina residents face medical debt that is in collections. That ranks this state fourth in the nation in unpaid medical bills.

For many of us, this may be the first Thanksgiving in which we’ve gathered with far-flung family members in several years; last year was still…

No one doubts that the Forsyth County Animal Shelter off University Parkway is a necessary and beneficial facility.

With most of the 2022 midterm election races settled — we’re still waiting to hear the results from a few stragglers — many of us hope our liv…

It’s a paradox of autumn that as our hemisphere cools, preparing for a long slumber, it also feels energized by the bright colors of fall foli…

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


Breaking News

News Alert